Everyone’s arguing about whether physical media is dying. Wrong debate.
The real question: what did PlayStation promise its customers, and does killing the disc break that promise or keep it.
Here’s the comparison people keep reaching for: “Netflix did the same thing. Killed DVDs, moved to streaming. Worked out fine.”
Wrong comparison.
DVD-by-mail was never Netflix’s anchor. It was the delivery truck. The promise was on-demand entertainment, no trip to the store, watch what you want when you want. Streaming didn’t abandon that promise, it delivered it better. Netflix used the same anchor to pioneer a new category.
PlayStation’s anchor isn’t “efficient game delivery.” That’s how Sony sees itself from the inside. From the disc buyer’s side, the promise was always ownership. You own it. It’s not going anywhere. No server, no subscription, no rug pull.
Killing the disc doesn’t serve that promise. It cancels it. Netflix made its anchor more true. PlayStation is making its anchor less true and hoping “here’s why it’s better for us” covers the gap.
It won’t. You can’t upgrade a promise you’re quietly revoking.
Sony’s own numbers: 85% digital, 15% disc. That’s still roughly 70 million people who went out of their way to buy something they could have just downloaded.
That’s not a rounding error. That’s the loudest, most loyal proof the promise still means something to somebody.
But the sales number isn’t even the real argument. The real argument is sitting on shelves.
Every disc anyone has ever bought on PlayStation is a receipt for a promise. Not “you can play this today.” “You own this, permanently, no matter what we do next.” Millions of people didn’t just buy a game. They built a library on that promise.
Killing new discs doesn’t touch old discs, sure. But it tells everyone holding one exactly what Sony thinks that promise is worth going forward: nothing. The next generation of PlayStation owners won’t get to build what this one did.
Losing the 15% isn’t a supply chain footnote. It’s the anchor coming loose, one collection at a time.
It’s not game over. Not yet.
Watch the full call.
Want your brand’s positioning anchor stress-tested before you find out the hard way? Ries.com → Positioning Hotline. Or start with The Strategic Enemy.
